Smart Lock Battle Encode Schlage-one Risk Stands Out
- 01. Smart Lock Security Comparison: Encode vs Schlage - Are They Truly Safe?
- 02. Core Security Features Compared
- 03. Connectivity & Smart Home Integration
- 04. Security Vulnerabilities & Patch History
- 05. Real-World Security Testing Results
- 06. Installation & User Experience
- 07. Price & Value Comparison
- 08. Final Verdict: Which Should You Buy?
Smart Lock Security Comparison: Encode vs Schlage - Are They Truly Safe?
The Schlage Encode Plus is the more secure smart lock compared to the original Schlage Encode, offering built-in Wi-Fi, Apple HomeKit support, Matter protocol compatibility, and enhanced firmware with automatic security updates that address vulnerabilities like the 2024 Bluetooth exploit. Both locks carry ANSI Grade 1 certification-the highest residential security rating-and use 128-bit AES encryption, but the Plus model provides superior long-term protection through regular patches and a more secure Bluetooth stack.
Core Security Features Compared
When evaluating smart lock safety, encryption strength, physical durability, and update frequency matter most. The original Schlage Encode launched in 2019 with built-in Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, while the Encode Plus arrived in late 2024 with next-generation security enhancements.
| Feature | Schlage Encode (Original) | Schlage Encode Plus |
|---|---|---|
| ANSI Grade Rating | Grade 1 (Highest) | Grade 1 (Highest) |
| Encryption Standard | 128-bit AES | 128-bit AES + Secure Bluetooth Stack |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi + Bluetooth | Built-in Wi-Fi + Bluetooth + Matter |
| Apple HomeKit | No | Yes (Home Key support) |
| Firmware Updates | Manual patches | Automatic updates |
| Battery Type | 4 AA batteries | 4 AA or rechargeable (sold separately) |
| Battery Life | ~6 months | ~6-8 months |
| Release Date | July 2019 | November 2024 |
The physical build quality remains nearly identical: both feature weather-resistant zinc alloy construction, a 1-inch deadbolt throw, and pick-resistant cylinders. However, the Encode Plus's secure Bluetooth stack directly addresses the critical vulnerability discovered in early 2024, where attackers could potentially intercept pairing signals.
Connectivity & Smart Home Integration
One of the key differences lies in connectivity architecture. The original Encode requires a separate Z-Wave hub (like Samsung SmartThings) for advanced automation, while the Encode Plus has integrated Wi-Fi eliminating extra hardware.
- Schlage Encode: Wi-Fi built-in but needs external Z-Wave hub for Matter/HomeKit; no Apple Home Key
- Schlage Encode Plus: Native Wi-Fi + Matter + Apple Home Key; works directly with Apple Home app without third-party setup
In independent testing, the Encode Plus achieved a 99%+ success rate on Apple Home Key unlocks on the first try, outperforming rival Yale Assure 2 Plus (98%) and Level Lock+ (90%). This reliability matters when you're carrying groceries or in a hurry.
Security Vulnerabilities & Patch History
In February 2024, security researchers discovered a Bluetooth pairing exploit affecting several smart locks including the original Encode, allowing nearby attackers to potentially capture handshake data. Schlage released a firmware patch within 30 days, but the Encode Plus launched afterward with a hardened Bluetooth stack preventing this attack vector entirely.
- Original Encode: Vulnerable pre-patch; requires manual firmware update to fix
- Encode Plus: Immune by design; receives automatic security patches quarterly
- Industry Trend: Experts predict the original Encode may be phased out by 2028 as Schlage focuses on Plus and newer models
The automatic update feature on Encode Plus ensures you never miss critical security patches, a major advantage over manual-update models where users often delay or forget updates.
Real-World Security Testing Results
During Bob Vila's 2024 reviewed tests, the Schlage Encode survived 50+ tampering attempts including drilling, bumping, and lock-picking tools, earning its ANSI Grade 1 certification. The motor strength scored 9.2/10, handling misaligned doors without jamming-a critical factor since 30% of home breaches occur through poorly latched doors.
"If Apple Home Key is your top priority, Schlage Encode Plus is the most reliable. It's nearly flawless with over 99% success on first try."
- Independent smart home tester, December 2024
Battery performance also impacts security: dead batteries can lock you out. The Encode Plus delivers 6-8 months runtime on four AA batteries, compared to 6 months for the original, thanks to optimized power management.
Installation & User Experience
Both models fit standard deadbolt preparations and include all mounting hardware, but installation complexity differs.
- Encode Plus setup: 15-20 minutes; no external hub required; direct Wi-Fi pairing
- Encode setup: 25-35 minutes; requires Z-Wave hub configuration for full smart features
The Encode Plus lets you create and manage access codes directly in the Apple Home app, eliminating third-party app dependency after initial setup. Voice control works with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple Siri on both models.
Price & Value Comparison
As of May 2026, pricing reflects the feature gap:
| Model | MSRP | Street Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Schlage Encode (Original) | $229 | $179-$199 | Budget buyers with existing Z-Wave hub |
| Schlage Encode Plus | $279 | $249-$269 | Apple users, future-proof security |
The $50-$70 premium for Encode Plus buys automatic updates, HomeKit support, and enhanced Bluetooth security-critical for long-term safety.
Final Verdict: Which Should You Buy?
Choose the Schlage Encode Plus if you want maximum security, Apple ecosystem integration, and future-proof protection through automatic updates. The original Encode remains viable only if you're budget-conscious and already own a Z-Wave hub.
The smart lock market is shifting toward integrated hubs and cyber security. The Encode Plus aligns with this trend, offering all-in-one convenience while the original may face obsolescence by 2028. For families, vacation rentals, or anyone prioritizing long-term safety, the Encode Plus's enhanced security features justify the modest price increase.
Ultimately, both locks are secure for residential use, but the Encode Plus eliminates known vulnerabilities through superior engineering and proactive patching-making it the definitively safer choice as of May 2026.
What are the most common questions about Smart Lock Battle Encode Schlage One Risk Stands Out?
Are Schlage smart locks truly safe from hacking?
Yes. Both Encode models use 128-bit AES encryption, ANSI Grade 1 physical security, and tamper-resistant designs. The Encode Plus adds automatic firmware updates and a hardened Bluetooth stack, making it significantly harder to compromise than the original.
What's the main difference between Encode and Encode Plus?
The Encode Plus has built-in Wi-Fi without needing a hub, supports Apple HomeKit and Matter protocols, offers automatic security updates, and includes a more secure Bluetooth stack fixing the 2024 vulnerability.
Does the Schlage Encode work with Apple HomeKit?
No, the original Encode does not support HomeKit. Only the Encode Plus supports Apple HomeKit and Home Key, enabling phone-as-key unlocking via the Apple Home app.
How long do Schlage Encode batteries last?
Both models run on four AA batteries for approximately 6 months. The Encode Plus can extend to 8 months and offers an optional rechargeable battery pack.
Will the original Schlage Encode receive security updates?
Schlage released a patch for the 2024 Bluetooth exploit, but the original Encode requires manual updates. The Encode Plus receives automatic quarterly security patches, ensuring continuous protection without user intervention.